Comparing the Used Clothing Recycling and Distribution Systems of Europe and China – China's Competitive Advantage in the Global Market
Introduction
The used clothing recycling and distribution systems in Europe and the United States have a long history, while China’s used clothing industry has rapidly emerged in recent decades, becoming a major global supplier. This article compares the differences in recycling methods, cost structures, circulation efficiency, policy support, and market acceptance between Europe and China. Additionally, it highlights the unique competitive advantages of Chinese used clothes (including shoes, bags, textiles, toys, and more) in the global market.
1. Historical Development of the Used Clothing Systems in Europe and China
1.1 The Early Development of Europe
The used clothing recycling system in Europe can be traced back to the late 19th century. Charitable organizations like Goodwill and the Salvation Army started systematically collecting used clothes in the early 20th century, repurposing them for social welfare. In recent years, with the rise of environmental awareness, second hand clothes have evolved into a popular consumption trend, particularly among the younger generation, as part of the sustainable fashion movement.
Europe's used clothes have been widely accepted domestically and have been exported in bulk clothing to developing countries in Africa, Asia, and other regions since the 1960s. Demand for second hand clothing from Europe in these regions is partly driven by brand recognition and quality.
 |
| https://unsplash.com/photos/goodwill-store-sign-XzVGz2HBtK4 |
1.2 China's Rapid Rise
China's used clothing industry developed much later but has grown rapidly, particularly since the 21st century, as the country began prioritizing environmental protection and resource recycling. The government has issued a series of policies supporting the recycling of textiles, encouraging businesses to drive bulk clothing collection and export.
Today, companies such as DODO Platform have established global supply chains and sorting standards, positioning China as a key player in the global used clothing market.
 |
| DODO Bird logo |
2. Differences in Recycling and Distribution Methods
2.1 Recycling Methods: Charity-Based vs. Market-Driven
In Europe, used clothes recycling is mainly driven by charitable organizations and community groups, with donations being a primary way clothing enters the recycling network. Additionally, Europe also has a robust estate and domestic cleanout service for recycling. Estate cleanout companies often handle large amounts of clothing from the deceased and repurpose them through sorting and resale or donations. This method supplements the regular community-based and charity-driven recycling processes.
In contrast, China’s recycling system is market-driven, with companies taking the lead. In particular, platforms like DODO have built their recycling networks, covering the entire country while focusing on collecting high-quality used clothes from upscale urban residential areas. These garments, due to their quality and fashion appeal, often become core inventory for customers purchasing Chinese second-hand clothing and earning high profits in subsequent distribution channels.
In China, the “internet + recycling” model has also flourished. Alibaba and WeChat have launched online programs allowing users to schedule home pickup services, making the recycling process efficient and convenient.
 |
| China’s online recycling platforms and offline recycling ecosystem |
2.2 Differences in Recycled Materials
European used clothes tend to feature minimalist designs and larger sizes, aligning with local preferences for understated colors like black, gray, and blue. Clothing sizes are also larger, reflecting the body types of the general population.
In contrast, China's bulk clothing offerings are much more diverse. Due to its vast geography and varying climates, China produces a wide variety of styles, colors, and fabrics. Moreover, the body types of Chinese consumers better match those in developing countries, particularly in Africa and Southeast Asia, where buyers favor more moderate sizes and vibrant colors. As a result, Chinese used clothes better meet the needs of these markets and represent a significant competitive advantage.
3. Comparing Costs and Efficiency
3.1 Labor Costs and Efficiency
Labor costs in Europe are high, particularly in the sorting and cleaning stages, resulting in a higher per-item cost for used clothing. Strict environmental regulations in Europe also require compliance during processing, further driving up costs.
 |
| USA GCI’s used clothing sorting factory |
In contrast, labor costs in China are relatively low, and the country benefits from high efficiency in its sorting and production processes. This leads to a significantly reduced cost per item. Furthermore, China’s high-efficiency factories offer a competitive advantage in the global supply chain, boosting China's pricing competitiveness in used clothing.
 |
| Used clothing sorting factory certified by DODO Bird standards |
3.2 Logistics Costs and Efficiency
China boasts a highly developed logistics network, particularly with the support of the Belt and Road Initiative. Cross-border logistics from China is cost-effective and time-efficient, with large volumes of bale clothes shipped through sea and rail. This stands in stark contrast to Europe, where logistics costs are higher and less efficient.
4. Circulation Efficiency: Traditional Networks in Europe vs. Digital Platforms in China
4.1 Traditional Distribution Networks in Europe
European second hand clothing distribution still heavily relies on traditional retail networks, such as thrift stores and charity shops. Although online platforms have begun to emerge, overall digital penetration remains low, and the distribution process is less efficient.
4.2 China's Digital Platforms and Mobile Internet
China’s mobile internet technology is far more advanced than that of Europe. The widespread adoption of mobile payment, logistics scheduling, food delivery, and courier services highlights China's digital infrastructure, which offers substantial efficiency advantages for used clothes distribution.
However, despite China's leading digital landscape, bale clothing transactions are still subject to certain limitations. Unlike new products, bulk clothes require time for sorting and quality checks, and customers often purchase based on brand trust rather than a "what-you-see-is-what-you-get" model. In this case, DODO ensures transparency by providing details about each batch's origin (e.g., high-end residential areas) and production line management, which enhances customer confidence.
 |
| Shenzhen, Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou |
5. Policy Support: Differences Between China and Europe
5.1 Policy Support in Europe
Europe’s policy support for the second hand clothing industry primarily focuses on environmental protection. The European Union introduced the Textile Circular Economy Action Plan, encouraging textile recycling and reducing landfill waste. The United States has also implemented state-level “green recycling” initiatives to promote recycling and environmental sustainability.
5.2 Policy Support in China
Since the early 2000s, China has progressively strengthened its support for textile recycling. The 2022 Implementation Opinions on Accelerating the Recycling of Waste Textiles sets a target of achieving a 25% recycling rate by 2025. These policies provide long-term institutional support for the industry while reducing operational costs through subsidies and tax incentives.
6. Shifting Trends in Market Acceptance
6.1 Market Acceptance in Europe
European consumers have a relatively high level of acceptance of second hand clothing. The growing trend of sustainable fashion has further fueled the popularity of used clothing. Many young people see buying second hand clothes as an environmentally friendly fashion statement. Some brands in Europe and the United States have even opened dedicated second-hand stores to cater to this demand.
6.2 Changing Attitudes in China
In comparison, used clothing acceptance in China has traditionally been lower due to cultural perceptions of used goods. However, as environmental awareness grows and the market develops, more young people in China are starting to embrace second hand clothes. In the high-end consumption sector, certain luxury second hand clothing items are also gaining popularity.
6.3 Global Trends: Preferences for Chinese vs. European Second-Hand Clothing
In global markets, developing countries are increasingly favoring Chinese bulk clothes, particularly in Africa and Southeast Asia. Chinese garments, known for their diverse styles and better fit for local populations, are gradually gaining market share, while European used clothes, constrained by size and style, are seeing a decline.
Conclusion
By comparing the differences between the used clothing recycling and distribution systems of Europe and China, this article highlights China’s competitive advantage in the global used clothes market. From highly efficient recycling systems and lower logistics costs to advanced digital infrastructure and strong policy support, China’s second hand clothing industry has established a robust presence on the international stage. As global interest in sustainable development grows, China’s bulk clothing exports are poised to continue expanding, making it a top choice for international buyers.
评论
发表评论